Book Review: The Outlaw Gunner, by Henry M. Walsh

However, readers can discover another aspect of Shore history and culture in Henry M. Walsh’s The Outlaw Gunner (1st ed., 1971, 2008, Tidewater Publishers; 2nd ed., Schiffer, 2020), a history of wildfowl hunting and market gunning, its culture, techniques, boats, decoys, wardens, traps, trappers, cannon, guns, gunners, and dogs. Walsh also helped to found the Eastern Shore Waterfowl Festival in Easton.
Walsh’s local history will interest even readers with little or no interest in shooting. Many of its 13 chapters have tales told with art and imagination, including gunners and game wardens playing hide-and-seek, hunters battling storms, large guns that explode and injure their users, and long vigils waiting for game that all add rich appeal to his historical research.
In the 18th and 19th centuries, waterfowl hunting was far more important to the local economy than now. Well into the 20th century, ducks and to a lesser extent geese provided locals with plenty of food as well as plenty of food to sell. Restaurants in Baltimore, Philadelphia, and New York bought many birds from the Eastern Shore, with Canvasbacks prized for their flavor. Eating establishments in those cities almost always had wild fowl on their menus.
In the early 20th century, fearing mass extinction of the nation’s bird populations, Congress passed the Migratory Bird Treaty Act (1918, with Canada and later other nations). This early environmental protection law made it illegal, without a permit, “to pursue, hunt, take, capture, kill, or sell” wild, native migratory birds or their parts. Waterfowl needed protection from market hunters, but the Snowy Egret was also hunted nearly to extinction to provide white feathers for women’s hats.
Market gunning resembles the 19th century movement overland to settle the West. Yes, the Eastern Shore had long been settled by Europeans, but its outlaw gunners demonstrated endurance and imagination aplenty. Working with few materials, reusing old equipment, and sometimes struggling for survival, these bird hunters’ resourcefulness and imagination matched the wagon-hauling pioneers.
For instance, outlaw gunners invented specifically-designed boats (sinkboxes, sneak skiffs) in which to stealthily approach large rafts of unsuspecting ducks floating on the water.
Giant “punt guns,” some with bores as large as two inches, were improvised and packed with large amounts of powder to take out dozens of birds at a single firing. Improvised firearms sometimes exploded, causing serious injuries. Made from steel pipes or reused shotgun barrels and bolted to the bows of shallow-draft boats, battery guns fired multiple barrels simultaneously and sprayed shot widely.
When the MBTA law suddenly restricted hunting, the gunners quickly shifted to night hunting, the better to continue shooting ducks without hindrance by the law.
Historians of market gunning have yet to declare its end date, likely because none exists. The 1918 law, of course, was honored in the breach. The 1934 Duck Stamp Act regulated season dates and bag limits, but made perhaps a bigger impact in funds for state wildlife agencies and in sponsoring the popular duck stamp art competition. Ducks Unlimited notes that in the 1930’s there were “changes to waterfowl hunting regulations. Live decoys, sinkboxes, baiting, and shotguns larger than 10-gauge were prohibited, and a three-shell limit was placed on repeating shotguns.” On the whole, outlaw gunning ended with not a bang but a whimper.
Although Walsh’s treatment of outlaw gunners is sympathetic, the book’s final chapter argues a conservationist’s point. The book’s purpose is “to call attention to the many problems and uncertain future of our waterfowl” (167). Continued commercial hunting would have brought both waterfowl and sport to extinction. Even so, deteriorating conditions in the Bay as well as development have diminished waterfowl nesting habitat and hampered ducks’ reproduction. Hunters or not, all Chesapeake Bay residents are obligated to support conservation and environmental protection efforts.
References
https://www.commonsenseeasternshore.org/eastern-necks-outlaw-gunning-skiff-history-of-a-mystery
https://chestertownspy.org/2020/11/10/the-return-of-the-outlaw-gunner/
https://www.wildfowlmag.com/editorial/destinations_wf_chesapeake_0809/280774
http://johninthewild.com/the-history-of-hunting-ducks-tolling-and-market-gunning/
https://easternshorejournal.com/a-piece-of-hunting-history-eastern-necks-gunning-skiff/
Jim Block taught English at Northfield Mount Hermon, a boarding school in Western Mass. He coached cross-country, and advised the newspaper and the debate society there. He taught at Marlborough College in England and Robert College in Istanbul. He and his wife retired to Chestertown, Md. in 2014.
Common Sense for the Eastern Shore




